Cocktail Sauce Brands

If you are looking for the best cocktail sauce brands, you may not know where to start. Condiments are a dime a dozen, and cocktail sauce is no different as there are so many different varieties on the market.

While this is sometimes a good thing as it gives you options to choose from, it can also be difficult. Difficult because you have to figure out which brands are the best and which ones are worthwhile.

Not every cocktail sauce brand is going to be a winner, as they all are made differently and are going to have their own flavor. Sometimes this comes down to personal preference as well as you may not like certain brands that other people like.

So you should always do your research to find out which brands are going to be the best ones to try out first. Keep reading to find out what cocktail sauce brand is the best and what other brands offer high-quality cocktail sauce options.

Also check out these comparisons: Nesquik versus Ovaltine and Milky Way or 3 Musketeers.

Best Cocktail Sauce Brand

If you are hunting for the best cocktail sauce brand, you should try Heinz cocktail sauce. This brand is not only known for its catch-up and other condiments, but it also creates a flavorful and zesty cocktail sauce that could complement any meal.

Homemade Spicy Cocktail Sauce

Heinz is definitely Mostly well-known for its ketchup products which it is the best seller for. But Hines also creates a variety of condiments that are all so delicious and full of all the flavors that you would expect them to have.

The cocktail sauce from Heinz is no different, as this cocktail sauce is full of flavor and ready to pack a punch. It is bright and zesty with plenty of spices added to kick up the flavor with any meal that you add it to.

It has that distinct red Color and is a staple that every kitchen should have on hand. Because Heinz is such a well-known brand, this is also a very easy condiment to find, no matter what grocery store you are shopping at.

Making it a convenient option that you can easily pick up anywhere.

Louisiana Fish Fry

Louisiana Fish Fry sauce comes from a brand that originated in Louisiana and started to cater to the seafood craze. Cocktail sauce is most commonly used as a condiment for seafood, so Louisiana Fish Fry became an expert at creating this condiment.

This is a traditional cocktail sauce, created originally from horseradish sauce, which gives it its bright and zesty flavor. It is the perfect condiment to add to any kind of seafood that you may be enjoying, but it is also very versatile.

This is a flavorful sauce that you can add to other meals as well as seafood to spice things up. It is full of traditional cocktail sauce flavor, and this brand specifically offers a few different kinds of sauce options that you can try.

As well as other fish fry condiments and spice rubs that you can use if you are going to be cooking seafood.

Old Bay

Old Bay is a well-known brand that hosts a line of seafood condiments, hence the name. The cocktail sauce from Old Bay is thick and full of traditional flavor with a hefty base of horseradish sauce.

It is most traditionally used with any kind of seafood that you may be cooking, such as oysters, fish, shrimp, etc. Though you could also get experimental and try adding this cocktail sauce to a variety of other foods as well.

You may not have many options when it comes to Old Bay cocktail sauce, but the original sauce is definitely a winner in most people’s books. If you are looking for a traditional-tasting cocktail sauce, this is definitely one brand to try out first.

St. Elmo’s

St. Elmo‘s is a restaurant based in Indianapolis that is a steakhouse that serves shrimp cocktails. It is known worldwide for its shrimp cocktails and its specialty cocktail sauce which it creates in the restaurant.

This is one of the best sellers at this restaurant, and eventually, St, Elmo‘s decided to start bottling its cocktail sauce and selling it. Because of this, now you can buy St. Elmo’s cocktail sauce at any grocery store, even if you don’t live near a steakhouse.

This cocktail sauce is made the traditional way with a base of horseradish to give it that zesty punch. But its overall recipe definitely stands out and has garnered a lot of attention from those who love cocktail sauce.

If you can find this brand in your local grocery store, this is a great cocktail sauce to try out. It is definitely going to yield a unique flavor and goes great with any kind of seafood that you may cook.


Inglehoffer is a family-owned brand that originated during the great depression. It is known for its bright cocktail sauce that is made with freshly grated horseradish to pack a zesty punch.

It is a great cocktail sauce to try as it is full of traditional flavors that you would expect to find but is not overwhelming. Many customers describe it as being a mild cocktail sauce with all of the necessary flavors, but none of them are overpowering.

So this is the perfect option for anyone who enjoys cocktail sauce but doesn’t want it to overpower their food. Inglehoffer is also a pretty well-known brand, so you should be able to find this cocktail sauce in most major grocery store chains.


Bookbinder’s is a restaurant located in Virginia that became very well known for its condiments. Because they were so popular in the restaurant, Bookbinder’s decided to start bottling and selling its condiments.

Now Bookbinder’s is a well-known name in grocery stores as you can easily find these kinds of condiments on the shelves. This includes a traditional cocktail sauce that anyone should try if they enjoy this kind of condiment.

You have the option of choosing a hot and spicy cocktail sauce or the original recipe depending on your preferences. Both are going to be full of flavor, but one is definitely going to pack a potter punch with your meal.

You should be able to find a wide variety of Bookbinder’s condiments in just about any grocery store that you shop at. Making it a convenient option as most people have access to it.


Beaver brand sells a very basic cocktail sauce that many people trust and rely upon. This is a traditional cocktail sauce recipe that is going to have that traditional flavor that you expect to find in this condiment.

It is bright and fiery with freshly grated horseradish that really packs a punch when you add it to food. It is considered to be a basic option as there is nothing that necessarily stands out about it as it is very traditional.

This is a very well-known brand that any grocery store is going to carry in the condiment aisle. Making it easy to find so that you do not have to go to any specialty store to pick up a trustworthy bottle of cocktail sauce for your meal.


McCormick is mostly well known for its seasons and spice blends that you can buy in the seasoning aisle of any grocery store. But it also sells two varieties of cocktail sauce that are full of flavor, as you would expect them to be from a spice company.

You have the option of buying the extra hot or the original McCormick cocktail sauce, depending on what you prefer. Normal cocktail sauce is already quite spicy and packs a punch, but the extra hot version is definitely for heat lovers.

Because this is such a well-known brand, it should be easy to find in any grocery store chain that carries condiments.

Primal Kitchen

Primal Kitchen is a unique brand that offers a variety of products that are healthy and very straightforward (here is a list of unhealthy products). Its mission is to create products that taste exactly the way they should with simple ingredients.

The cocktail sauce from Primal Kitchen has no added sugar and is considered to be whole 30 and keto friendly. It is a healthier option that tastes very flavorful, allowing you to taste every ingredient that is included in the sauce.

This is definitely a healthier option that will help you to not feel guilty if you like to eat a lot of cocktail sauce.

You can read more about the best flour tortilla brand and find out what the best lemonade brand is.

Which Cocktail Sauce Brand Is Better?

If you are looking for the best cocktail sauce brand, Heinz is definitely a trustworthy brand that you should try out. It is best known for its ketchup, but Heinz also carries a bunch of condiment options as well as cocktail sauce.

It is also very easy to find in stores as this is a new brand everywhere you go. If you want to try other kinds of cocktail sauces, you can try Old Bay, St. Elmo’s, Beaver, McCormick, or Bookbinder’s.

These are just a few brands that offer top-quality cocktail sauce options that everyone should try at least once. They all have their own unique flavor and are going to spice up a variety of different meals.