Does Honey Mustard Go Bad? – Full Analysis

Does Honey Mustard Go Bad? – Full Analysis

Honey mustard is a popular condiment that is both a little bit tart and sweet. This type of food is often served as a dipping sauce to Wings, french fries, small bite-size food, or it is used as a coating to flavor foods. Honey mustard is an ancient food once used by the Romans.

Does honey mustard go bad? Yes, honey mustard goes bad. But it does not go bad for a long time. If it is unopened and stored in a cool, dry place, and the bottle or jar is never tampered with, it can last for up to three years. But once the bottle or jar of honey mustard is opened, it must be stored in the refrigerator. If it is in the refrigerator, it can last for up to a year and a half.

How Long Does Honey Mustard Last if Unopened?

Depending on the quality of ingredients used in honey mustard and the number of preservatives the food manufacturer places in the sauce, it can last for a long time. A basic plastic bottle of honey mustard can last for a year in a cupboard or pantry as long as it is unopened. But if that bottle of honey mustard is placed unopened in the fridge, it can last up to two years.

The reason why honey mustard lasts longer in the fridge than in the pantry, even though both bottles in this scenario are unopened, is because the refrigerator is at a constant temperature. The bottle of honey mustard in the refrigerator will not experience any temperature change.

In contrast, the bottle of honey mustard in the pantry is subject to the heat in the cold as the summer and winter months occur. 

How Long Does Honey Mustard Last if Opened?

Most items, especially ones in bottles or cans, deteriorate faster once they’re opened compared to when they are sealed. But honey mustard does pretty well, as long as it is stored correctly.

Once a jar or bottle of honey mustard is open, it must be placed in the fridge. Refrigeration is required, especially if the honey mustard has any amount of mayonnaise. As long as it is stored in the fridge, and it is not left out too long on the countertops whenever it is used, an open container of honey mustard can last up to a year.

How to Tell if a Container of Honey Mustard has Gone Bad?

Because of its and sweet flavors, detecting if a container of honey mustard has gone bad is more difficult than other types of foods. This is why it is so important to keep this condiment in the fridge.

One way to tell if the sauce has gone bad is if the liquids in the containers separate after leaving alone for a while. But, that doesn’t always mean it has gone bad. Some sauces and condiments, especially ones that are made from high-quality ingredients, separate naturally.

But if you notice that your honey mustard is separating when it never has before, that is a possible sign.

How to Store Honey Mustard

Whatever type of honey mustard you purchase, it is relatively easy to store. All that must be done is store the bottle or jar of honey mustard in a cool and dry place. Or, if you want the condiment to last a long time, you can place it in the back of the refrigerator, even if it is unopened.

If it is open, then it must always be refrigerated. Do not leave an open jar of honey mustard in the cupboard or the pantry. It will go bad quickly.

Also, because of its unique and tangy flavor, many people cannot tell when the condiment is starting to turn bad. So they won’t be able to use the smell and taste test to determine if the contents of the bottle or jar are rotting. 

How Long Does Honey Mustard Last? Shelf Life [Chart]

Type of Honey Mustard Length of Time
Honey Mustard, unopened, pantry 1-2 years
Honey Mustard, unopened, fridge 2-3 years
Honey Mustard, open, fridge 1 year

What is Honey Mustard?

The condiment called honey mustard is quite simple. It is just the combination of honey and mustard. While these two flavors taste radically different, once they are combined together, they create a unique flavor that is enjoyed everywhere around the world.

Different types of honey and mustard worldwide, each culture that has these two players have their own version of honey mustard. You will find honey mustard in North America and the EU, China, East Europe, and parts of Africa. 

What most people do not know about honey mustard is that it is not a recent invention. It is an ancient one. The Romans had both mustard and honey in their cuisine and created the first honey mustard sauce by combining mustard seeds and honey with several types of spices and boiling them together.

What are the Ingredients of Honey Mustard?

The main ingredients of a honey mustard sauce are honey and mustard. But not all honey mustard is made the same way. Plus, to help the flavors combine together and create a unique taste, other ingredients are added to the sauce. Also, not all honey mustards have the same type of honey and mustard inside of them.

Some honey mustard sauces use special types of mustard in order to draw out a more in-depth flavor in the sauce. These bold and interesting sauces are found more in high-end stores that carry several types of honey and several types of mustard. 

In addition to the types of honey and mustard, they’re also other ingredients in the condiment. Some makers of the sauce include sugar, even though there is honey. They will also add salt to boost the flavor. Surprisingly, water is also added to honey mustard because the honey thickens up the sauce.

Preservatives like citric acid help the sauce for me shelf-stable to last on grocery store shelves for four months and years. If some ingredients cause the condiment to take on a strange color, a food manufacturer will also add a coloring agent to give their honey mustard a uniform yellow color their customers are used to. 


  • Honey mustard is a condiment or sauce made out of mustard, honey, and a few other ingredients. It is used mostly as a dipping sauce for wings, pretzels, potato-based foods, and other snacks.
  • Honey mustard is enjoyed in different parts of the world, as many countries have some form of mustard and honey.
  • Although many people associate honey mustard with the modern palate, it actually has ancient roots.
  • One culture we know of that enjoy honey mustard is the Romans
  • Many types of honey and mustard can be combined together to create the condiment.
  • Along with honey and mustard, other ingredients for the condiment include sugar, salt, preservatives, mayonnaise, and natural spices.
  • A jar or bottle of honey mustard can last from one to three years if unopened and stored in a cool, dry place.
  • Once a bottle or jar of honey mustard is opened, it must be stored in the refrigerator.
  • An open container of honey mustard can last up to a year, as long as it is stored in the fridge.
  • In order to make an unopened container of honey mustard last as long as possible, it can be stored in the fridge.
  • Storing honey mustard and any other type of condiment in the back of the fridge is best because it will not go through temperature changes whenever the refrigerator door is open.