Steak Sauce Brands

Steak sauce goes well on steak and other meat dishes. Before you buy the first brand you see, consider if it’s the best option.

Sometimes, it may be your only choice. However, there are so many brands that you should compare a few options.

What Are the Best Steak Sauce Brands?

The best steak sauce brands include A1, Heinz, and Mr. Spice. Other brands to try include 365, Peter Luger, and Lea & Perrins. Shula’s, Prime Choice, and Andria’s are three more options if the others don’t work for you.

Be sure to shop around in your local grocery store and other stores to get the largest possible selection. If all else fails, there’s also the internet thanks to retailers like Amazon.

Best Steak Sauce Brands

When preparing a juicy steak, you may want to add a sauce. But if you haven’t done so before, you may wonder what sauce to get. You could get whatever store brand is available, but that’s not always the best choice.

Steak Pieces with Sauces

Here are some of the best steak sauce brands to use the next time you make a steak.


A1 is probably the most famous steak sauce brand. The original steak sauce is a classic, and you may have had it without knowing that’s what you had. You can buy the steak sauce in a standard bottle, which is great for use at home.

However, they also sell the sauce in single-use packets. That’s a great option if you want to host a cookout. On the other hand, you can stock up with large jugs of the sauce, and that’s smart if you have a large family and will go through the sauce fast.

You can also buy thick and hearty sauce, which may be more like barbeque sauce. They also sell marinades to add flavor right to the meat.


Heinz 57 Sauce is versatile and can work well as a steak sauce. It has a tomato puree base along with over 100 spices. You can add the sauce when you serve steak or use the sauce to marinate the meat ahead of time.

If you like Heinz condiments, you’ll probably like this sauce. Sure, it’s not a true steak sauce, but that’s what makes it great. You don’t just have to use it for steak, so you can go through it more easily and not waste the sauce.

Mr. Spice

Mr. Spice sells another slightly less traditional steak sauce. This sauce is a garlic steak sauce variety, and it’s more of a marinade. However, you can use the sauce on your steak to add flavor.

It’s organic and free of salt and fats, so it’s relatively healthy. If you want to watch what you eat but treat yourself to a steak, use this sauce. You can also buy the other varieties if you want to get different flavors when making steak.


365 by Whole Foods Market also carries its own steak sauce. The sauce is organic and vegan, though the vegan part may not matter when you use it with steak. However, it can be nice because you know it doesn’t contain dairy.

Whether you need to keep kosher or are lactose intolerant, you can consume the sauce. You can find it in your local Whole Foods store. Amazon also sells it, but it’s not always in stock, so going to the store is your best option.

Peter Luger

Peter Luger makes an excellent steak sauce that works for your classic steak dish. But you can also use the sauce on vegetables and other foods. This sauce is sweet, sour, and salty, and it can taste great.

It’s a bit thicker than some steak sauces, so it’s between steak sauce and barbeque sauce. You can use it as a marinade, and you can add it to chicken and fish as well as steak. It can taste a bit like a cocktail sauce, but it doesn’t contain alcohol.

Lea & Perrins

Lea & Perrins steak sauce is another fantastic option. Now, it does contain fish, so you may want to keep that in mind if you don’t eat seafood. However, it’s kosher, so you can eat it on many different diets.

The sauce is a bit tangy and sweet, so it can taste great on steaks and other dishes. It doesn’t contain fat or cholesterol, so it’s nice if you want to watch what you eat. Unfortunately, you may not be able to find it in a grocery store, but you can order it online.


Shula’s steak sauce is gluten-free, and it tastes similar to A1 sauce. This brand is a bit more expensive than A1, and it can be harder to find. However, you may want to give it a try to see if you like the brand better.

If not, you can switch back to A1. Some people have said there’s a very minimal difference, and this sauce isn’t worth the higher price. But if you like supporting smaller brands, you may prefer to buy Shula’s.

Prime Choice

Prime Choice steak sauce is another less common option that’s worth trying. Finding it in stores can be almost impossible, but it’s easy to find online. You can even buy a pack of a few bottles so that you don’t have to buy more all of the time.

Some like the sauce better than A1, Heinz, and other top brands. Of course, it comes down to personal preference, so you need to try it for yourself.


Andria’s is yet another smaller steak sauce brand that may be easier to find online. It’s the sauce that they use at Andria’s restaurant in O’Fallon, IL. If you’ve gone there and liked it, you’ll want to buy this sauce to use at home.

Even if you haven’t been to the restaurant, you can enjoy this sauce. And if you like it, you can decide to take a trip to visit the restaurant. Then, you can have the sauce on your favorite menu items.

Rufus Teague

Rufus Teague sells original steak sauce as well as spicy steak sauce. If you like a bit of heat, you’ll want to try this brand with your next meal. The bottle is a bit small, so it’s somewhat expensive per ounce.

However, you can use it on any meat you make, from steak to chicken. That way, you can add a unique spin to any recipe.

Steak Sauce vs. Barbeque Sauce

As you shop for steak sauce, you may wonder if you can substitute barbeque sauce. Some steak sauces are similar to barbeque sauces. But barbeque sauce is generally thicker, and it’s easier to use barbeque sauce in more dishes.

Steak sauce tends to be a thinner consistency. The sauce is most suitable for topping your steak with, but you can use some sauces when making other meats.

How to Choose Steak Sauce?

If you want to get the best steak sauce, you have to think about a few things. Here are some important factors to help you choose the right steak sauce brand for you.

Check Your Store

Of course, you have to make sure the sauce you want is available. Some grocery stores may only sell one or two steak sauce brands.

If you’re willing to shop online, you can access more brands. But there may be stock issues. So what was available the last time you bought steak sauce may or may not be available now. You might need to be flexible with the sauce you buy.

Buyer with soy sauce in store

Consider Your Budget

Next, think about how much money you have to spend on steak sauce. Most brands are pretty cheap, but some cost more per ounce. While you may not use the whole bottle now, you could use it over a few weeks.

If you have a small budget, consider what will cost the least in the long run. Then, you can make the most of your grocery budget and put more money toward a better cut of steak, for example.

Shop for Sales

A great way to save money on your steak sauce is to wait for a sale. Of course, this means you need to be patient.

But you can stock up on your favorite brand when the price is lower. You can also buy certain brands in bulk to save money at any time.

Make Sure It’s Steak Sauce

Finally, you want to make sure the product you choose is in fact steak sauce. Since steak sauce and barbeque sauce are very different, you need the right product.

This is particularly important if you’re following a recipe for a marinade. Some brands also stock their various sauces right next to each other, which can be confusing. Read the labels carefully, and don’t hesitate to ask for help if you need it.

Final Thoughts

The best steak sauce brands include A1 and Heinz. But you can find other smaller brands, such as Andria’s. Be sure to try a variety of sauces until you find one that you love. Then, you’ll look forward to making your next big steak dinner.